Kariki Research
Young Forests, Fast Carbon: Stand Age and the Rate of Forest Carbon Sequestration

Abstract
Whether young forests sequester carbon faster than old forests depends on the unit of comparison. This paper reviews seven peer-reviewed studies to establish what the evidence supports. At the scale of the forest stand, it supports the claim clearly. Regrowing Neotropical forests absorb a mean 3.05 tonnes of carbon per hectare per year in their first 20 years, eleven times the rate of old-growth forest (Poorter et al. 2016). A global synthesis of 13,112 field measurements finds that IPCC default rates understate early regrowth uptake by 32% on average (Cook-Patton et al. 2020). Stands regrowing after disturbance account for 1.30 Pg C per year of the global forest sink, against 0.85 Pg C per year in intact old growth (Pugh et al. 2019). The decline in stand productivity with age is driven by falling photosynthesis, shifting carbon allocation and declining tree density. At the scale of the individual tree the relationship reverses: annual carbon gain rises with tree size (Stephenson et al. 2014), and old-growth forests remain net sinks (Luyssaert et al. 2008). We conclude that establishing new forest is the fastest way to add sequestration, that protecting old growth is essential to avoid emissions, and that credible carbon accounting requires site-, species- and age-specific measurement.
1. Introduction
Forest carbon claims face growing scrutiny from buyers, regulators and researchers. One frequently repeated claim, that young trees sequester carbon faster than old trees, is often stated loosely, and in its loose form it is open to challenge. This paper sets out the precise form of the claim that the evidence supports, summarises the primary studies behind it, explains the mechanisms, and states its limits.
Section 2 defines the claim. Sections 3 and 4 present field and global evidence. Section 5 explains the mechanisms, section 6 sets out the limits, and section 7 draws implications for forest carbon accounting.
2. Defining the claim
"Young trees sequester carbon faster than old trees" is true or false depending on what is being compared, so precision matters before any number is quoted.
• Per hectare of forest (the stand): young and middle-aged stands accumulate carbon faster than old stands. This is the comparison that matters for land use, reforestation and carbon credits, and it is well supported.
• Per individual tree: the opposite holds. For most species, a tree's annual carbon gain keeps rising as it grows larger. Old stands grow slower overall because they hold fewer trees, not because each old tree has stalled.
The defensible version of the claim is therefore: young, regrowing forests sequester carbon faster per hectare than mature and old-growth forests. That is the claim the rest of this paper evidences.
3. Field evidence: regrowth rates
Two large field syntheses, both in Nature, measure how fast regrowing forests accumulate carbon.
Poorter et al. (2016), Neotropical secondary forests. The team analysed biomass recovery across 45 sites and about 1,500 plots spanning the major climates of Latin America. After 20 years, regrowing forest had recovered an average of 122 tonnes of above-ground biomass per hectare. That equals a net uptake of 3.05 tonnes of carbon per hectare per year, which the authors calculate as 11 times the uptake rate of old-growth forest. Converting carbon to CO2 (multiply by 44/12), that is roughly 11 tonnes of CO2 per hectare per year. Recovery is not instant: biomass took a median of 66 years to reach 90% of old-growth levels.
Cook-Patton et al. (2020), global natural regrowth. This study compiled 13,112 georeferenced field measurements of carbon accumulation in the first 30 years of natural forest regrowth and mapped potential rates worldwide at one-kilometre resolution. Two findings stand out. First, rates vary more than 100-fold across the globe, driven mainly by climate. Second, the default rates used by the IPCC underestimate early regrowth accumulation by 32% on average, and by 53% in the tropics.
Taken together, these studies show that the first decades of forest growth are a period of rapid carbon gain, and that generic default factors misstate it badly in both directions.
4. Global evidence: where the forest sink lies
Young forests hold most of the world's current forest carbon sink. Pugh et al. (2019), writing in PNAS, combined a global database of forest ages with a vegetation model to split the sink between old-growth and regrowing stands. For 2001–2010 they estimate:
| Forest type | Net carbon sink (Pg C per year) |
|---|---|
| Stands regrowing after past disturbance | 1.30 (range 1.03–1.96) |
| Intact old-growth forest | 0.85 (range 0.66–0.96) |
Regrowing forests, which the accompanying university release describes as stands under 140 years old, therefore account for roughly 50% more of the sink than old growth. The authors attribute close to half of the regrowth sink to forest demography alone, meaning the simple fact that these stands are young. They also warn that this sink is transient: as today's regrowth matures, its uptake will fall away unless new forest is established.
5. Mechanisms: why young stands are faster
Forest growth follows a well-documented curve: stand productivity rises quickly after establishment, peaks when the stand is young or middle-aged, and then declines. Foresters have long used this curve to set rotation ages; ecologists have spent decades explaining it.
• Photosynthesis declines with stand age. Tang et al. (2014), analysing a global database of forest carbon fluxes in PNAS, found that net primary production falls as boreal and temperate forests age, driven mainly by a decline in gross photosynthesis rather than by rising respiration costs.
• Carbon is partitioned away from wood. In a controlled experiment on even-aged stands, Ryan et al. (2004) found above-ground wood production fell faster than canopy photosynthesis, as a larger share of carbon went below ground and to foliar respiration.
• Fewer trees, more competition. As stands mature, trees die and density falls. Dominant trees keep growing strongly while suppressed trees slow, so the stand's total growth drops even as its biggest individuals thrive.
The last point is also why the individual-tree and stand-level findings do not contradict each other.
6. Limits: large trees and old-growth forest
Two findings qualify the stand-level result and should always be stated alongside it.
Big trees add the most carbon per tree. Stephenson et al. (2014) analysed 403 tropical and temperate species in Nature and found that, for most, a tree's mass growth rate rises continuously with size. At the extreme, one large tree can add as much carbon in a year as an entire mid-sized tree contains. In their western US old-growth plots, trees over 100 cm in diameter were 6% of stems but produced 33% of annual growth. The authors explain the stand-level decline through falling tree density, which matches the mechanism above.
Old-growth forests keep absorbing carbon. Luyssaert et al. (2008), reviewing carbon-flux studies in Nature, found that forests between 15 and 800 years old usually remain net carbon sinks, overturning the view that old forests are carbon neutral. They estimate the boreal and temperate primary forests of the Northern Hemisphere alone sequester about 1.3 billion tonnes of carbon a year, and they warn that much of the carbon stored in these forests, soil carbon included, would return to the atmosphere if they were disturbed.
The practical conclusion is not "young beats old". It is that new forest is the fastest way to add sequestration, while protecting standing old growth is the surest way to avoid releasing carbon. Clearing old forest to plant young forest loses carbon for decades.
7. Implications for forest carbon accounting
The evidence supports a forestry model in which old-growth native forest is protected and working forests are grown, harvested and replanted. Each replanting resets a stand to the fast-sequestering phase of its growth curve, provided the harvested timber goes into long-lived products and the land returns to forest promptly.
It also explains why carbon must be measured rather than assumed. Rates differ more than 100-fold by location, shift steeply with stand age, and are understated by generic defaults. A credible credit has to reflect the site, the species and the age of the trees actually growing, tracked over time. That is the gap Kariki is built to close: estimating sequestration per hectare from site-, species- and age-specific growth models, so that every credit traces back to measured, growing forest.
8. Conclusion
Young, regrowing forests sequester carbon faster per hectare than mature and old-growth forests. The finding is consistent across field plots, global syntheses and model-based partitions of the global sink.
It does not follow that old trees or old forests matter less. Large trees add the most carbon individually, and old-growth forests remain substantial sinks and stores. The implication for policy and markets is a portfolio: protect what stands, regrow what has been lost, and measure each hectare on its own terms.
References
- Poorter, L. et al. (2016). Biomass resilience of Neotropical secondary forests. Nature 530, 211–214.
- Cook-Patton, S. C. et al. (2020). Mapping carbon accumulation potential from global natural forest regrowth. Nature 585, 545–550.
- Pugh, T. A. M. et al. (2019). Role of forest regrowth in global carbon sink dynamics. PNAS 116, 4382–4387.
- Tang, J. et al. (2014). Steeper declines in forest photosynthesis than respiration explain age-driven decreases in forest growth. PNAS 111, 8856–8860.
- Ryan, M. G. et al. (2004). An experimental test of the causes of forest growth decline with stand age. Ecological Monographs 74, 393–414.
- Stephenson, N. L. et al. (2014). Rate of tree carbon accumulation increases continuously with tree size. Nature 507, 90–93.
- Luyssaert, S. et al. (2008). Old-growth forests as global carbon sinks. Nature 455, 213–215.