All articles

Kariki Blog

Forests Are Not Enough

· Colin Weir

Forested islands surrounded by clear ocean

Kariki in 60 seconds

Kariki is software for the forest economy to clean our air, protect and restore nature and fix our climate. It connects the people who grow, harvest, trade and finance timber, so that timber and carbon credits can be traced back to real, well-managed forests.

Why? Forests are worth more standing and growing than the market recognises. As a result illegal logging continues unabated and undercuts legitimate growers of plantation forests and protectors of native old growth forests. Contemporaneously carbon markets suffer from too few credible credits, largely because growing trees aren't properly measured or tracked.

Kariki works along the value chain. Timber reaches market only from licensed operations that replant as a condition of their permit. Revenue from that timber cycles back into new planting and into the tax system to fund additional grants. Old growth rain forests are preserved not only for their carbon but most importantly their biodiversity and ecosystem preservation. Forests are measured by site, species and age, so the carbon and ecology they store can be counted with confidence.

We don't replace the good providers already working in this space; we connect them. We're starting in Australia, New Zealand, the Pacific and South East Asia, working with landholders large and small. Learn more at kariki.cloud.

We get to choose

We are at an inflection point, and what we do now will echo for a very long time. Everyday each of us wakes up we get a choice: shape the world, or let the world shape us. My choice is to lean heavily on the first. I've done that everyday of Moroku's 15 years effecting change on how financial service providers think about using financial fitness as a telos to everything they do.

Born in the mountains of New Zealand and the laboratories of Canterbury University, Kariki exists to protect and grow forests. We want less illegal logging and deforestation, better forestry, more trees in the ground and more stable land. That work matters, but forests are not enough on their own. No single fix is.

350, not 450

In 2007, NASA climate scientist James Hansen argued that stabilising carbon dioxide at the widely cited 450 parts per million would not be enough. He urged bringing it down toward 350. We have since passed 420.

Trees can pull some of that carbon back out of the air. Sequestration is part of the answer, and it is the part Kariki works on. But you cannot plant your way out of a problem you keep adding to.

Getting to 350 means we have to stop polluting. That means replacing fossil electricity fast and at enormous scale.

The conversation we keep avoiding

Solar and batteries are part of the mix. But I'm not convinced they will get us there alone, at the scale and pace required and in a manner that is sustainable across their supply chains. There are too many vehicles, too many batteries and solar panels to be made and then recycled and too many people and things to move and power. Every way I look at it, we need a proper conversation about nuclear.

That means fission today, and fusion as it matures from experiment into something we can build. Fission splits heavy atoms such as uranium to release heat, and has powered electricity grids for about 70 years. Fusion joins light atoms together, the process that powers the sun, and leaves far less long-lived waste, but no one has yet built a commercial fusion power plant. There is an answer in there, and we need to keep investing in the R&D.

Nuclear is a subject where dread often arrives before understanding. Fear ahead of knowledge. Much of that dread is a Cold War hangover, combined in stories such as the Rainbow Warrior in New Zealand and more emotional than evidenced. When public fear and emotions takes nuclear off the menu, electricity demand doesn't disappear and everyone becomes more complicit in kicking a very heavy ball down the road for our grandchildren to deal with . Coal usually fills the gap. I made this case in Britain has started a Manhattan Project. Australasia is still doing studies, and my view hasn't changed: it's time to bring our thinking up to date with the science and move on.

The waste problem is solvable

The biggest public fear around nuclear is its waste, because it feels like a toxic gift forced on the distant future. The answer lies in scale and containment.

If all the electricity one American uses in a lifetime came from nuclear, the high-level waste would fill roughly a soda can. From coal, it would mean about 68 tons of solid waste, with the carbon dioxide vented straight into the air. Nuclear waste also becomes less dangerous over time, as its radioactivity decays.

Spent fuel cools in pools, is sealed in steel-and-concrete dry casks at reactor sites, and can then go into deep geological storage. Finland has shown that last step can be done. Its Onkalo repository, carved about 430 metres into ancient bedrock, has cleared its final safety review, the first such facility anywhere to reach the operating licence stage.

Fusion changes the question again. The honest claim is not zero waste. It is that, with low-activation materials, most fusion waste decays to hands-on levels within about a century, against tens of thousands of years for fission's high-level waste. Neither waste is weapons-usable and as me shift from fission to fusion and we will we shift the needle from a hundred thousand years to a hundred.

There is a broader rule of thumb that is useful here: concentrate what is harmful and contain it, rather than spreading it everywhere. A small volume, sealed and watched, beats ash and gases dispersed through our air, water and soil. Every time I watch an old truck or car puff its way up a hill or tear around the country side driven by a human or supplied by an operator, that doesn't care or understand their complicity I shudder.

Planetcraft

Humanity now acts as a geological force. The atmospheric chemist Paul Crutzen popularised a name for this: the Anthropocene. Its echo is long. The carbon we emit today, like the waste we bury, will shape the planet for tens of thousands of years.

That is why Stewart Brand calls for "planetcraft": the practical discipline of acting with restraint, watching the results, and correcting course early. It takes great science and great engineering together, and it means looking across the whole ecosystem rather than one piece at a time.

A good starting point is to treat ecosystems as natural infrastructure. Mangroves, forests, reefs and soils do real work for society, from storm protection to supporting fisheries. Yet those benefits rarely show up in market prices.

Thailand shows the cost. From the 1980s, vast areas of coastal mangrove were cleared for shrimp farms that were highly profitable to their owners. But when the analysis came in, the picture flipped. A UN study put a shrimp farm's value at about $200 per hectare once pollution and lost services were included. Intact mangroves, which buffer storms, shelter young fish and supply local communities, were worth roughly $1,000 to $36,000 per hectare. Answer - Do the maths end to end not on the business plan for a shrimp farm

This is the gap Kariki is built around: forests whose value is real but unmeasured, and so too easily cleared.

Measure, research openly, govern early

Concentrating and containing harm is the easier part of planetcraft. The harder part is knowing what our interventions are doing, and here we often lack sustained measurement. Oceans are the clearest gap: they shape air, rain, clouds and climate, yet their depths and chemistry remain thinly observed.

When measurement and mitigation still fall short, a more unsettling option enters the conversation: solar geoengineering, cooling the planet by reflecting a small fraction of sunlight back into space has been discussed. It seems like a ways off with much more research to be done, shared and peer reviewed in the open, so that choices aren't made in panic.

Political scientist David Victor argues that rushing into treaties, or treating the topic as taboo, can backfire. Science can solve this. Politics will never. We need to invest in the research and be considered. Solar geoengineering is cheap enough for a single country to attempt on its own. A ban would block responsible testing without preventing reckless action.

That puts governance at the centre: who decides, and who gets to act? Smallpox eradication offers a precedent. A small unit within the World Health Organization set the strategy and standards, national teams did the fieldwork, and shared surveillance data held the effort together. We acted together. This can slow things down but despite our urgency this is when getting it right matters.

Victor expects norms for geoengineering to grow the same way, through shared data, conferences and real-world tests. That's how one universal Internet came about: engineers agreeing on what worked, not treaties.

Where Kariki fits

Planetcraft, in the end, is scaling and realising our combined responsibility: protecting natural infrastructure, measuring honestly, sharing what we learn, and governing power before a crisis forces our hand. Kariki hopes to play its part in that.

Our part is forests. We want timber reaching market only from licensed operations that replant, revenue cycling back into new forests, and growing trees measured properly so carbon credits mean something. That is stewardship backed by science and engineering.

But we are not claiming a silver bullet. We need cleaner power, and that means a grown-up conversation about nuclear. There is a lot still to learn, and plenty of failures still ahead of us. Between complacency and doom there is a third path: lean in, do the work, and let understanding arrive before dread.

Ma Te Rongo Ka Mohio.

From Listening Comes Knowledge

Sources

  • James Hansen et al., "Target Atmospheric CO2: Where Should Humanity Aim?" (2008)
  • Gwyneth Cravens, Power to Save the World (2007), source of the soda-can and 68-ton comparison
  • Stewart Brand, Whole Earth Discipline (2009)
  • Onkalo SNF repository passes safety assessment, American Nuclear Society, August 2026
  • Posiva repository clears safety review, Nuclear Engineering International
  • Comparing the Economic and Social Value of Mangroves and Shrimp Farms, World Resources Institute
  • Valuing Mangrove Conservation in Southern Thailand, ELAW
All articles